Log in to your portal
PPE needs to provide appropriate protection for the day-to-day hazards likely to be present, but it also needs to be suitable for the task, the working environment and the person wearing it.
If any of these factors are overlooked, even the best quality, and compliant PPE may not provide the level of protection expected. So how can you tell when PPE isn't quite right for the job? Here are seven signs that your current PPE may need to be reconsidered.
Workers are regularly removing or adjusting it
One of the clearest signs that PPE isn't working for the wearer is that they don't want to wear it.
If workers frequently remove PPE, loosen it, reposition it or make unofficial adjustments during a task, there may be an underlying problem with the equipment.
Comfort is important, but this isn't simply about whether PPE feels pleasant to wear. Equipment that is uncomfortable, restrictive, too hot or difficult to use can affect how consistently it is worn.
For example, a worker may remove eye protection because it repeatedly fogs up, loosen hearing protection because it becomes uncomfortable over a long shift, or adjust protective clothing because it restricts movement.
These behaviours shouldn't automatically be treated as a failure to follow instructions. They can be a useful indication that the PPE selection needs to be reviewed.
The goal should be PPE that workers can wear correctly and consistently while carrying out their work.
Your PPE doesn't work well together
PPE is rarely worn in isolation.
Depending on the task, a worker might need a safety helmet, hearing protection, eye protection, respiratory protection, gloves, protective clothing and safety footwear at the same time.
Each item may be suitable individually, but that doesn't necessarily mean the combination is suitable.
For example, eyewear may interfere with another piece of face protection. Ear defenders may not sit correctly alongside a safety helmet. Respiratory protective equipment can affect the way other forms of face protection are worn.
This is why PPE selection should consider the complete combination of equipment, rather than assessing each item separately.
If workers are having to choose between two pieces of PPE because they cannot comfortably or correctly wear both, that is a sign the overall selection needs attention.
The PPE protects against the wrong hazard
Not all PPE provides the same type or level of protection.
A product may look appropriate for a particular task but offer little protection against the specific hazard involved.
Consider gloves as an example. A general-purpose work glove isn't automatically suitable for chemical handling, heat exposure, sharp materials or tasks requiring a high level of cut resistance.
The same principle applies across other PPE categories.
Before selecting equipment, it's important to identify:
- What hazards are present?
- How severe could the consequences be?
- How long might the worker be exposed?
- What type of protection is required?
- Are there multiple hazards that need to be considered?
- Does the PPE provide the appropriate level of protection for the task?
PPE should be selected based on the hazard and the risk, rather than simply choosing a familiar product.
The working environment has been overlooked
The same PPE can perform very differently depending on where and how it is being used.
Temperature, moisture, dust, chemicals, poor visibility, confined spaces and outdoor conditions can all influence PPE selection.
For example, PPE suitable for an indoor environment may not be the best option for prolonged outdoor work in wet or cold conditions. Similarly, equipment that works well in a cool environment may become difficult to wear comfortably during physically demanding work in high temperatures.
Environmental conditions can also affect the lifespan and performance of PPE.
When reviewing PPE, consider the conditions workers encounter day-to-day rather than relying solely on how the equipment performs in ideal circumstances.
PPE is being modified to make it easier to use
If workers are cutting, drilling, taping, removing or otherwise modifying PPE, this should be treated as a warning sign.
Unofficial modifications can affect the performance or protective properties of equipment and may mean that it is no longer being used as intended by the manufacturer.
More importantly, modifications often indicate that the original PPE isn't meeting the needs of the task or wearer.
Instead of simply replacing the modified item, it is worth asking why the modification was made in the first place.
Was the PPE uncomfortable?
Was it interfering with another piece of equipment?
Was it restricting movement?
Was it unsuitable for the working environment?
Understanding the reason behind the modification can help identify a more appropriate solution.
The equipment meets the relevant standard, but isn't necessarily suitable
Compliance is important. PPE needs to meet the applicable requirements for the protection it is intended to provide.
However, meeting a standard doesn't automatically make a product suitable for every situation.
A standard establishes requirements for a particular type of protection. It doesn't replace the need to consider the specific workplace, task or wearer.
For example, two products may both meet the relevant standard but differ significantly in fit, design, materials, comfort, compatibility and suitability for particular working conditions.
This is why PPE selection should not stop at checking a certification or standard marking.
Ask a broader question:
Is this PPE appropriate for the actual task our workers are carrying out?
Compliance should be viewed as a fundamental requirement — not the entire PPE selection process.
Nobody is sure when the PPE needs replacing
PPE doesn't necessarily last forever.
Some equipment may show obvious signs of damage or wear, while other deterioration can be harder to identify. Exposure to sunlight, chemicals, heat, moisture, abrasion and repeated use can all affect different types of PPE.
Workers should know what signs to look for and when equipment needs to be replaced.
Depending on the product, this could include:
- Cracks, tears or deformation
- Excessive wear
- Damaged fastenings or components
- Loss of protective properties
- Contamination
- Changes in fit
- Damage following an incident
- Reaching a manufacturer's recommended replacement period
A PPE management system should make it clear who is responsible for inspection, maintenance and replacement.
If workers are unsure whether equipment is still suitable for use, that's a sign that the process may need to be reviewed.
The right PPE is about more than the product
It's easy to think of PPE selection as a straightforward purchasing decision: identify the required category, choose a compliant product and issue it to workers.
In reality, effective PPE selection is much more involved.
The equipment needs to work for the hazard, task, environment and wearer — and it needs to work alongside any other PPE being used.
This is particularly important because PPE is often considered the last line of defence in the hierarchy of controls. Where risks cannot be eliminated or adequately controlled through other measures, PPE has an important role to play in protecting workers from residual risks. That makes appropriate selection, correct use and ongoing maintenance essential.
Ask workers what isn't working
One of the simplest ways to identify problems with PPE is to speak to the people using it every day.
Workers may notice issues that aren't immediately obvious during a formal assessment.
- Is the equipment uncomfortable?
- Does it interfere with another item?
- Is it difficult to put on correctly?
- Does it become impractical during certain tasks?
- Are workers taking it off during parts of the job?
These observations can help employers identify whether the PPE currently being used is genuinely suitable.
Worker feedback should form part of the wider PPE selection and review process, alongside risk assessments, manufacturer information and relevant standards.
PPE should support safe working, not get in the way
The best PPE isn't necessarily the most expensive, most advanced or most heavily featured option.
It is the equipment that provides the appropriate protection while allowing the wearer to carry out their work safely and effectively.
If PPE is uncomfortable, incompatible, unsuitable for the environment or inappropriate for the hazard, it may be time to reconsider the selection.
Ultimately, the question shouldn't simply be:
"Does this PPE meet the required standard?"
It should be:
"Is this the right PPE for this worker, doing this task, in this environment?"
Getting that answer right can make PPE more than a box to tick. It can make it an effective part of a wider workplace safety strategy.
This article provides general information and should not be treated as a substitute for a suitable and sufficient risk assessment or specialist health and safety advice. Always refer to current HSE guidance and applicable legislation when determining PPE requirements for your workplace.
